Photo by Mingzhen Lu, Princeton University and Santa Fe Institute
World’s thinnest roots are ‘underground weapons’ in ecological competition
Most of us only think about the easily visible parts of plants — stems, flowers, leaves — but in a new study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Princeton ecologists Lars Hedin and Mingzhen Lu show that the hidden root systems beneath a South African brushland hold the answer to a biological puzzle.
“For the last 400 million years, ever since plants moved from the oceans to colonize land, roots have been the engine driving the water cycle, the nutrient cycle, the carbon cycle, worldwide,” said Lu, lead author of the new study and a 2018 Ph.D. graduate in Princeton ecology and evolutionary biology who is now the Omidyar Complexity Fellow at the Santa Fe Institute.
Hedin, Princeton’s George M. Moffett Professor of Biology and professor of ecology and evolutionary biology and the High Meadows Environmental Institute, went a step further: “These are the world’s thinnest roots, and they essentially hold the secret to biodiversity on the biome scale.”
Anyone who has weeded a garden knows that roots can be finer than threads or human hairs. The roots found by Lu, Hedin and their colleagues from the University of Cape Town, the South African Observational Network, Hebrew University of Jerusalem and the Chinese Academy of Sciences, are much, much thinner — so remarkably thin and so long that a single root stretching the length of 15 football fields weighs just one gram, the same as a paperclip.
These roots underlie the fynbos biome, a dry brushland in South Africa that is the most ecologically rich biome in the world outside of the tropics, with more than 7,000 different species of plants, of which the great majority exist nowhere else. And in a longstanding biological mystery, the fynbos exists side-by-side with towering trees in the Afrotemperate forest biome that have only a tenth of its diversity.
Lu described the startling sharpness of the boundaries between the shrubland and the forest biomes: “In the summer, you are scorched by the sun in the fynbos, then you take one step into the forest, and you’re engulfed by cool humidity and you see moss on the trees,” said Lu. “It’s like a binary switch, zero to one. Boom, you’re in another world.”
For over 100 years, ecologists have debated what produces these strikingly contrasting ecosystems. The sharp delineation was even more puzzling because the two biomes share an underlying geology and the same climate and weather conditions. To answer the question, the authors of the PNAS study conducted a four-year experiment involving 40 plots in which they manipulated soil nutrients and the ability of forest seedlings to compete with the native fynbos plant community.
They discovered that the two biomes exist as alternative stable states in the same environmental conditions.
“Some systems can exist in different states — like water and ice,” Hedin said. “This makes them especially interesting as models for dramatic change because they can switch from one state to another in response to perturbations, which is especially urgent in a world being stressed by climate change.”
In this environment, the remarkably thin roots are a competitive strategy. They allow the tough but beautiful fynbos plants to thrive in the poorest soil in the world — an almost pure quartz sand.
Hedin cited Princeton’s rich history in the field of game theory as he described the ecological competition at play in the fynbos.
“We’re taking principles of game theory into a biological system, and this can explain the emergence of biodiversity patterns,” he said. “What’s novel here is that the roots — the world’s thinnest roots — actually play a central role in this game. Because if you have them and I try to invade with my thicker roots, you will capture every nitrogen atom before I can and there’s not many of them in this soil to start with. And it’s not just one species doing this, but the whole community has evolved with this strategy, making the soil just too miserable for anything else to survive.”
“This paper breaks startling new ground,” said coauthor William Bond, a professor of biological sciences at the University of Cape Town. “We now see that it is not the intrinsic soil properties, but plant feedbacks to the soil that create misery for forest saplings. The thin roots of the fynbos are the below-ground weapon creating miserable conditions for nutrient-demanding forest plants. The image of an Erica root spreading across 15 football fields, versus a forest tree root spreading across just a single field, is a vivid illustration of how root geometry can radically influence below-ground nutrient acquisition.”
In addition to the root advantages, the fynbos also is prone to frequent, hot fires that burn accumulated nutrients in the soil. The researchers determined that fires have burned periodically for millions of years, and that the fynbos plants have evolved ways to weave their lives around fire events. Most fynbos species time their major life events — flowering, seed dispersal or seed germination — to conditions created by fire.
The forest trees have very different properties focused on fire resistance; regeneration of forest trees is set back by fires, never promoted. The nutrient-hoarding below-ground strategy combined with pro-fire adaptations allow the fynbos plant community to favor its own persistence by modifying its environment. On the other side of the biome divide, the forest is doing the same thing.
Previous research by Hedin and Lu has delved into the oft-invisible strategies plants use to ensure their dominance, which ripple out to produce the mosaic of biomes that support our planet’s various plant and animal species. A 2019 paper they published suggested that the organization of forests worldwide are based on the ancient relationships that plant species forged with soil-dwelling microbes that enhance the uptake of nutrients. A new theory of plant evolution they published in 2018 suggested that the 400 million-year drive of flora across the globe may have been propelled by underground root adaptations that allowed plants to become more efficient and independent as soil quality dropped north and south of the tropics.
The new findings published in PNAS suggest that alternative stable states can be maintained through biotic mechanisms, such as roots competing for rare resources, in addition to the commonly understood abiotic factors like climate and underlying geology. This insight is critical to conserving threatened ecosystems around the world, the researchers noted.
“As humans, we think that bigger is always better,” Hedin said. “’Be as productive as possible.’ ‘Competition makes trees grow bigger.’ That has driven biological theory for more than a century. Our research suggests that there’s a completely different strategy here, and it depends on manipulating your environment.
“Keep the soil miserable, burn any nutrients that try to accumulate,” he said. “I mean, these plants don’t have brains, but over evolutionary time, it’s a strategy that works.”
“Biome boundary maintained by intense belowground resource competition in world’s thinnest-rooted plant community“ by Mingzhen Lu, William J. Bond, Efrat Sheffer, Michael D. Cramer, Adam G. West, Nicky Allsopp, Edmund C. February, Sampson Chimphango, Zeqing Ma, Jasper A. Slingsby and Lars O. Hedin appears in the current issue of the Proceedings of the National Academies of Science (DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2117514119). The research was supported by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, the Princeton University Petrie Fellowship and the Santa Fe Institute Omidyar Fellowship.
Aaron Sidder with the Santa Fe Institute contributed to this story.